Baldur's Gate 3: A Player's Choice

A look into the dilemma of a Baldur's Gate 3 player who regrets their ethical choice of rescuing a character while giving up a rare item.

In the rich narrative world of 'Baldur’s Gate 3', players shape the storyline through their actions and decisions. Recently, one particular player has expressed regret for prioritizing morality over material gain.

In the game's third act, players encounter a character named Valeria. Uniquely, she is an investigator involved in a murder investigation at the Open Hand Temple, putting players in a moral dilemma.

An Unexpected Digital Love Encounter
Related Article

Interestingly, Valeria's narrative arc intersects with a series of challenges that players can engage in to unlock the coveted Bhaalist Armour, an exceptionally rare piece of in-game equipment.


To obtain the renowned Bhaalist Armour, players need to embrace the dark side and side with the divine entity Bhaal, thereby taking up the title of the Unholy Assassin. A necessary part of the ritual to acquire the title involves killing none other than Valeria herself.

The moral conundrum posed in this situation has been a topic of discussion among players. The aforementioned player chose to save Valeria instead of obtaining the armor and has expressed their remorse for choosing the ethical path.

After freeing Valeria, the player discovered that Valeria misattributed the guilt of the Open Hand Temple murder to an innocent refugee. This revelation sowed seeds of regret in the player's heart about their decision-making strategy.

The player later expressed their disappointment, stating that they would have rather had the Bhaalist Armour than save Valeria. This insight came too late and left them in frustration over the lost opportunity to acquire the rare piece of armor.

Further into their post-game analysis, the player noted that Valeria had once praised their character, Tav, for his virtues including courage, insight, and heroism. However, they claimed that they did not exhibit these qualities when they chose to save Valeria instead of acquiring the armor.

Refining the Player Experience in Baldur's Gate 3: Food Consumption Mechanism
Related Article

Feeling wronged by the incident, the player voiced that killing Valeria must not be considered an evil act anymore. Instead, it can be justified as an attempt to curtail corruption.

As reactions to the incident continued to pour in within the game's community, it seemed that the outlook towards Valeria progressively worsened amongst the narrative's followers. Other players reported receiving a post-game letter from Valeria where she subtly admitted to solving the murder mystery in their absence.

The nuisance created by Valeria and the misappropriated credit for solving the murder case led a user to label her as 'not a great example of Hollyphants,' a breed of celestial, kind-hearted elephants in the game.

This incident sparked a broad discussion amongst players regarding the value of in-game morality, with many agreeing with the original player's sentiments. Several players admitted to resorting to killing Valeria, more out of contempt for her character than for the prize of acquiring the Bhaalist Armour.

One user went on record to state that they do not hesitate to commit the 'evil act' of killing Valeria during every run of the game, favoring the game's rare armor over her life.

This incident places the consequences of player choices in video games under the spotlight, reigniting the debate around ethical decision making in gaming narratives.

These discussions prove the interactive narrative's capacity to incite a wide range of emotions and debate among players, reaffirming video games as a powerful medium for storytelling.

Valeria's narrative arc and the associated moral conundrum serve as an excellent example of how 'Baldur's Gate 3' successfully weaves intricate narratives to deepen the gaming experience.

As the moral compass swings, the gameplay intensifies, and players' decisions continue to redefine the landscape of Baldur's Gate 3, making it a critically acclaimed storytelling masterpiece.